Old Weapon Models

[kid908]

these are old weapon models and would like your opinion on where the inaccuracy is because i'm planing on remaking most of them. the one that i'm definately remaking is the mauler. the one shown here has a very messy mesh.

http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n211/kid908/Image_05-15-2008_08-17-39.jpg

http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n211/kid908/Image_05-15-2008_08-19-35.jpg

http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n211/kid908/Image_05-15-2008_08-21-19.jpg

more soon. it's time to go to school

[Geo]

Can't see a whole lot from those renders. The SL doesn't look too bad. Get a better render and then give it some smoothing.

[Hunter]

They don't look to bad.

[PenGuin1362]

Except the mesh is an absolute disgusting mess.

[SnaFuBAR]

wireframes please.

[jngrow]

Except the mesh is an absolute disgusting mess.
How can you tell? No wireframes. (this is an honest question, not questioning your statement or anything, just wondering)

[kid908]

i'll get wireframe soon. just w8 a bit. and some mesh are a mess since i haven't edit these much and they were made when i just started modeling.

[Roostervier]

How can you tell? No wireframes. (this is an honest question, not questioning your statement or anything, just wondering) It isn't hard to notice the many non-planars that are all over the models, especially on the spartan laser. It could also mean that he has hard edges where he shouldn't or the proportions are wrong.

[PenGuin1362]

How can you tell? No wireframes. (this is an honest question, not questioning your statement or anything, just wondering)

because he's posted these before with wireframes.