Quote Originally Posted by MMFSdjw View Post
There is a difference between a proper critique and just being a jackass.
A fair middle ground would be to say that the model sucks and provide a link to a google search of modeling tutorials. And he didn't even ask for tutorials, he didn't even ask for help.
That's exactly fucking right. So, instead of providing him with the tuts he didn't ask for (even though we still recommended it) we told him (in a decently not-mean way) that his model sucks. Aside from monopoly, nothing was wrong with those posts, and the only other thing is the debate about whether it'd be practical or not. Since he gave no real details, I think it would, in fact, be safe to assume that they are making a racing map. So the members took it upon themselves to discuss the idea. What's the problem in that? Forums are about discussion.

Honestly, what was wrong with the crit on the model? We told the truth. Last I knew, the truth was not considered unconstructive, or inflammatory. Maybe that's changed. If it has, someone please say so. That way, the next time I decide to tell the truth, I'll think twice. Then I won't get into more trouble for it. >: |

As for the OP. Could you show us any more pictures? Even if you aren't that great of a modeler, someone on your team could be. I'm interested in seeing some of their work.