Quick-Crit 2008-2009

[JunkfoodMan]

There isn't really anywhere you can look it up, except using designs from h1, h2 and h3 and modifying it.

Unless there is somewhere that has some specific rules we must abide by so that the structures are classed as forerunner.

In a way, there are certain rules. But if you've remade a structure from Halo 1, and it doesn't look like it's forerunner, clearly you've done something wrong.

[il Duce Primo]

absolutely not.

Fucking play the god damn game before saying it's completely not the style! It's one thing to just disrespect someone, but then you don't even support it with helpful criticism. People come here to help one another. What I see you doing is putting others down on a forum. I don't know if you have been having bad days lately, but wise up. If you truely mean to help someone, help them. Otherwise there's no reason for you to post.

[Higuy]

It looks forerunner to me, just fix the top spike thing so ones lower then the other. I think it may look better that way.

[teh lag]

Forerunner style or not? Also crit pleas

absolutely not.

I think you are wrong, they are in H1 only I remodelled them to have more detail.

Go and have a look.

If you were already convinced that it was in that style, why did you even bother asking? That exchange there made no sense at all. You said you wanted to know, and so he gave his opinion.

Fucking play the god damn game before saying it's completely not the style!

I'm pretty sure Snaf has played the game

[JunkfoodMan]

Fucking play the god damn game before saying it's completely not the style! It's one thing to just disrespect someone, but then you don't even support it with helpful criticism. People come here to help one another. What I see you doing is putting others down on a forum. I don't know if you have been having bad days lately, but wise up. If you truely mean to help someone, help them. Otherwise there's no reason for you to post.

He said "absolutely not", not "absolutely not you'll never be good ever".
He made a point about it not looking forerunner. So what should he do? Make it look more forerunner. The resources are out there, so he should use them to create successful forerunner architecture. IMO it does not look like forerunner, so maybe he should look at the structure he remade and see where he went wrong.

[Timo]

What they look like in-game. I'd say the spikes you've put on the top have killed the forerunner look in it. Not sure what you'd replace it with, though.

[rossmum]

Thanks for the negative feedback snaf. I'm also very sorry it is not up to your standard. I only stated my opinion hence the words "I think". When you leave negative feedback, please leave a comment so I actually know why you left it rather than a stupid period.

Sorry you don't like being told the fucking truth.

The spikes killed it, it doesn't look Forerunner anymore. And if you're going to take that attitude every time you get an answer you don't like, then don't bloody well ask.

[il Duce Primo]

Sorry you don't like being told the fucking truth.

The spikes killed it, it doesn't look Forerunner anymore. And if you're going to take that attitude every time you get an answer you don't like, then don't bloody well ask.

If you want to help someone the last thing you ever do is put them down. What he said might have been true but you never have to say it in such a disrespecting way. Snaf didn't even follow through with any help. He has not gained any amount of knowledge from Snaf's post.

[Evil_Monkey]

Sorry you don't like being told the fucking truth.

How is it the truth when he says it looks absolutely nothing like forerunner? It has some resemblance of forerunner.

[mech]

You post a picture of a model you can make in 5 minutes and want crit on it,

You have to show more in order to recieve the proper criticism.