Quick-Crit 2010

[ODX]

Not that I want to seem like I'm on Sel's side at all(seriously Sel your art sucks, nowhere my fap material standard), but this just screams "WAH WAH look at me I'm special".

I'm not trying to say I'm "special," I'm saying in a general way that it really kind of ticks off and disappoints the person who had worked hard on something and wanted a little bit of critique to help them evolve.

[Cagerrin]

Not that I don't sympathize with the idea, but your wording was... whiny, at the very least.

[Sel]

"Know what happened? Someone, I forget who, came in and posted some barely-started model of whatever. Everyone completely ignored what I had posted after that, and it just made. me. sick."

Not that I want to seem like I'm on Sel's side at all(seriously Sel your art sucks, nowhere my fap material standard), but this just screams "WAH WAH look at me I'm special".

I'm fully aware that my drawings are terrible.

I am posting them here to get in hopes of getting feedback that will help me improve them, instead of BAWWW FURFAG

[Timo]

Know what happened? Someone, I forget who, came in and posted some barely-started model of whatever. Everyone completely ignored what I had posted after that, and it just made. me. sick.

Why is there not a rule against this (posting work before another receives comments)? In no way is it fair to the person who worked damn hard on something and really wanted to see what others thought...then they get a big "fuck you" in their face and no one gives a shit about what they did anymore because "Oh look a few modeled planes! Let's comment on this!"

I don't intend to start an argument, I just really want to bring up this topic up and learn why people are so inconsiderate, and why nothing is ever done to fix the wrongs done.

Not everyone knows how to give constructive crit to animations, I sure as hell don't. Posting in this thread doesn't guarantee that you'll get some crit on what you post, it's just a thread to put your work out into the spotlight, and hope that someone will be nice enough to comment on it.

[ExAm]

I get it now. Sel's trolling. Commence ignoring of his posts.

[Sel]

I'm 12 baw baw baw baw baw

^^

I get it now. Sel's trolling. Commence ignoring of his posts.

are you really this dumb?

[ODX]

Not everyone knows how to give constructive crit to animations, I sure as hell don't. Posting in this thread doesn't guarantee that you'll get some crit on what you post, it's just a thread to put your work out into the spotlight, and hope that someone will be nice enough to comment on it.

If you read what I had said, I'd said I was looking for critique on the animations as well as general opinions from the public/non-animators since they would be the ones who mostly use my weapons and it matters what they/you have to say as well.

So I post it here, to see what they think because most of the time I could just bother ICEE or another animator on Xfire about it.

[p0lar_bear]

Christ.

This shit stops now.

Sel, first and foremost, use your head. Even the cleanest furry art sparks controversy thanks to the reputation the fandom is infamous for. If you're going to post poses for critique here, could you please at the very least pose your characters in fashions that the average person won't see as suggestive or softcore porn?

Everyone else, this is the quick-crit thread. This thread is meant for posting things for feedback, or for providing feedback to the posted media. Critique the work, not the subject matter. If you feel a post is objectionable, use the report post button.

If I come back in here and see another piece of borderline-clean art, infraction. If I come back in here and see another bitchfight over said piece, or hell, anything else, infractions. You've been warned.

[kid908]

I love how I post a render of something for opinions, and we end up with a page and a half of arguments over disturbing furry images haha

sorry your stuff just got squashed under the shit storm.

I think you can add more details such as plate rims and such. right now, it get's very thin at the edge and that look for armour isn't something I like(this is kind of a personal preference).

[Hunter]